These are beautiful looking foiled shadows which are absolutely chockfull of pigment. Plum diddy is (as the name suggests) a deep metallic plum with a hint of sparkle. I don't often wear super dark colours on my eyes so I personally like to apply this quite lightly and sheer it across my mobile lid, blending it into the crease with a matte cool brown. When worn sheer in this way it looks like a light brown/plum and is really flattering and wearable.
Guns and Rose petals is a soft pale pink and is incredibly metallic. It makes a super vibrant inner corner highlight similar in tone to Makeup Geek Whimsical. The texture of this is a little chunky so has to be blended out with the warmth of your fingertips.
While I love the colours and pigmentation of these shadows they crease absolutely terribly on me. I have tried these with a variety of primers including Mac Paint pot and had creasing with all of them. This means I rarely reach for them, particularly if I need my shadows to last more than an hour or two.
If you aren't prone to creasing shadows or have oily teary lids like me then I would absolutely recommend these- they are a great price and are beautiful shadows. However because of the unsightly creasing I wont be purchasing more shades.
I have one of these eyeshadow in the shade plum diddy. Seriously love the names of These! This shade is a beautiful dark eggplant with red glitters in it. It's very intense on the eyes but absolutely gorgeous.
The packaging is very similar to color pop. It's in a screw top container with a clear lid to see the colour. I much prefer the black container compared to colour pops white one. The texture of the shadow is quite similar too. I think these are slightly creamier though.
I've tried to wear this in a few ways, with different eye primers, powder shadow underneath and even powder shadow in a very similar colour on top. Unfortunately, no matter what I try, it creases really quickly and just looks so messy. I can't even get a full hour before this starts transferring and creasing on me. I do have slightly hooded eyes that are oily but generally eye primer makes shades behave on me.
I love this colour so much but I can't recommend it at all. I do have to say that the balmsai palette by the balm has a very similar shade in it. It's just a little darker and without the pretty red glitters but still a bit shimmery.