I wasn't sure what to expect as I hadn't used the original one, but I liked Rosewater as the ingredient on other products.
I found this great for my facial area - even when i had "heavier than usual" makeup (with primer, corrector, foundation, concealer!) Cleansing water was effective without being too oily or too dry. I personally liked the odour it was leaving on my skin, it felt very feminine.
However, it did not seem to work on my smudge-free mascara, even after leaving on my eyelash for a while! To be fair, I hadn't found any cleansing water that works on my mascara (those really good eye make up removers only).
Not too sure on the "natural glow" the product is asserting to, but it was quite nice and am open to switching to this product given the right pricing.
I LOVE Garnier Micellar Water. My favourite is the Garnier Micellar Cleansing Water in Oil, so this particular variant had a lot to live up to.
I loved the packaging - it's so pretty! And the scent is floral but not overpowering. I used this micellar water as directed - applied to the Garnier Reuseable Eco Pad, and it did a good job of removing my makeup. Good, but not as good as the Oil variant, which seems to really get in there and disintegrate my makeup with ridiculous ease.
Will I use this variant up? Yes. Because it works. Would I recommend? Yes. Would I repurchase? No, but only because another Garnier Micellar Water has my heart.