NYX Professional Makeup Butter Lipstick Review

I had been wanting to try these since they came out and managed to grab some when NYX had a 40% off sale. I got the shades Hubba Bubba, Big Cherry, Little Susie, Sweet Tart and Licorice.

As their name suggests, these lipsticks are supremely buttery. In fact, these are the most comfortable lipsticks I have ever worn. They feel extremely creamy applying them and once applied. They have a slight gloss finish and are really pigmented as well as hydrating.

I found that the lighter colours aren't as pigmented as the darker colours and need at least two coats if you want them opaque. The darker colours, however, are extremely pigmented and require only one coat.

Because they are so creamy, their lasting power isn't that great. After about an hour - two hours I found I need to reapply them. I don't mind this though because they feel so good on your lips.

I love the packaging of these - the fact that the tube is the colour of your lipstick is really helpful when they are in your lipstick collection as you can immediately see which colour you are after.

These are something I would definitely recommend and I want to try out other shades from the range.

I heard a lot of good things about the NYX Butter Lipsticks from Youtuber Shaanxo so when I saw a NYX stand on holiday at Target I had to pick up one and try them for myself!

The formula is as 'buttery' as the name suggests, smooth and creamy. It glides on like a dream and the pigmentation is fantastic, so one quick swipe is all you need for gorgeous colour. I love how moisturising they are, the nourishment of a lip balm but with the colour payoff of a lippy.

I was really suprised about the claim to be long-lasting. I found that as I expected with such a creamy lipstick these wear off after a couple of hours and do need to be applied after eating or drinking anything.

I plan on stocking up on Butter Lipsticks when I have the chance, they're such an easy-to-wear product. "Sweet Tart" is now one of my favourite everyday lippies for at work and I've had so many compliments wearing the colour, as well as since 'enabled' a friend to purchase it for herself!

I have two colours now: "Sweet Tart" is a medium cherry-pink, and "Razzle" is a bright, fuschia pink.

I saw some great reviews and swatches of these and considering they are affordable I went a little crazy and brought 9 from Urban Outfitters site.

I am very pleased with the colours I brought. There is maybe 1 or 2 I could do without. I haven't tested them all to great extent but the ones I have have been what I expected. They claim to be long lasting, I found they do last better then other cheap brands I've tried (especially better then the NYX round lipsticks!) without eating I found them find for 2-3 hours. Once I eat though all bets are off. Which is fine, they're affordable!

The packaging is a little tacky with all the writing on it, but the clear middle showing the colour is useful.

They're super creamy! Super hydrating. They glide on, some more pigmented then others but I'll get into that next as I list the colours.

I have (from light to dark):

POPS, a nude pinky beige colour. Nicely pigmented, hydrating and creamy.

TAFFY, a pretty light pink. It's quite sheer I find compared to the others. But just as creamy and hydrating.

LITTLE SUSIE, darker mid pink. Nicely pigmented. It's my favourite pink out of the bunch I got. A very sweet and pretty colour.

SWEET TART, is very similar to Little Susie but more sheer (but build-able) it's a touch darker too.

RAZZLE, is a bright fuchsia pink. Pigmented and creamy.

JUJU, I first saw this colour worn by Shaaanxo in a video which looked really pretty. It's a red but very wearable as it's lighter then most reds I've seen. This one is nicely pigmented too.

MARY JANE, is a true red shade, darker then Juju. Its one of my favourites even though it scares me a little. I say this as I steer more towards matte reds due to them being easier to wear (more long lasting) but this one is great as it's more hydrating then a matte. I just need to be more careful and able to do regular touch ups.

HOT TAMALE, is a loud true orange. If you like orange this is definitely one to try. It's very pigmented! I haven't been brave enough to wear this out yet!

HULK, is a dark purple, with a slight red to it. Now this looks super dark in the bullet but applies quite sheer, which is disappointing. But it's build-able! It's not what I expected considering all the other dark shades were true to colour and pigmented.

So like a lot of product lines, there are hits and misses but from my collection they have all been creamy and hydrating and even the sheer ones have been build-able.

I think these are a lot better then some other lipsticks in this price range and the colour selection is awesome. The colours are very wearable and universal in my opinion.

I recently purchased 2 of the NYX Butter Lipsticks, as I love the butter lipglosses I just had to try the lipsticks also!

I have the colour's Liquorish, which is the perfect winter season colour! It is a really deep black cherry colour, It is by far my favourite. I have Hunk, which is my least favourite out of the 3 I own, just because it looks like a really nice deep plum/red but when applied it is quite sheer, its still nice its just not what I expected. And the last one is Snow Cap. Which is a really nice nude, kind of a your lips but better colour, It is perfect for minimal makeup days, I also wear it to work a lot.

So firstly, I will say that these lipsticks do not last long, They are very creamy which does make them bleed a bit, I always apply a lip liner but after an hour the lip colour definatly looks worn, I wouldn't suggest wearing these if you are going out to eat ha :D

But, they are really affordable, there is a good selection of colours to choose from, and they have a nice finish for the short while they stay on your lips. The colours I have except the one mentioned, are really opaque and have a nice creamy finish.

I probably wont buy anymore of the NYX Butter Lipsticks just because there are a lot more affordable brands I prefer, plus I like the NYX Black Label Lipsticks a lot more! But I think for the colour selection and price I would recommend them to someone just starting out with makeup or experimenting with colour.

I purchased a selection of these off of NYX directly recently during their huge 4th of July sale and was awesomely impressed! Firstly I ordered them as I loved how cute they looked with the barrel and lid of the lipstick container matching its colour to the lipstick inside and have heard nothing but good things about them.

As mentioned above they have the cutest packaging for lipsticks in this price range, with their branding embossed in white and the easy to use twist up motion and a lid that snaps shut rather than sort of closes and then pops off in your bag kind of lid, this means that I can safely carry my lipstick with me throughout the day should I need a top up.

Lasting power shown by the butter range is great, I applied the 2 coats in the morning, blotted and only needed to top up after lunch for a full day coverage, this was mainly the case for the darker shades but found that a couple of the pink/salmon tones tend to wash away on my face during the day, regardless if I have eaten or drunk anything.

The lipstick itself is very luxurious to put on, it does feel like butter but not in the gross way, it’s smooth and almost melts onto your lips for a plump full look with even coverage of its highly pigmented colour. I have 8 of these that range from light beige, reds, pink, coral and deep plums, out of all of them my favourite is Liquorice it’s the most perfect purple plum I own without being over the top.

I recently purchased my first ever NYX Butter Lipstick, and I have to say, I am impressed!

I have the shade Big Cherry; a really pigmented, vibrant red.

The formula is silky smooth and glides on really easily, it has a gloss finish to it. It leaves a nice, hydrated feeling to my lips. I wore this all day and into the late evening, and not once did my lips feel dry, chapped or start 'cracking'. This is a huge, huge plus for me, as i work in air conditioning and my lips are forever dry!

I had minimal bleeding, (I didn't use a liner), although due to the creaminess of the formula, it does smear easily.

The staying power is quite good, I found I only needed to re-apply a top up after lunch and dinner.

I can't wait to try out some of the other colours in this range.

I recently ordered NYX products from Cherry culture for the first time when they were running 40% off sale. Perfect timing, I went crazy and ordered loads of NYX products to try. Pricing of butter lipstick is reasonable and affordable. Why we don't get these beauties in NZ in our local store I wonder. They will sell out in no time for sure.

I bought two shades in butter lipstick range - Little susie (pink) and Hunk (purple). Both these colors are gorgeous and really stand out. The lipstick literally melts on my lips when I swatch, it glides smoothly. I didn't have to apply any lip balm as the lipstick is so moisturising and buttery that it keeps my lips hydrated for long. I have been playing with the brightness of the shades for past few days. Both the colors I could either go light for daily work wear or I could build the color to bright shades for evening/party wear. The color lasts long on my lips which is great.

I love the packing of these lipstick range, they are the true colors shown on the cover as well. The lipstick as such doesn't have any smell or taste, I was expecting it to smell or taste fruity.

I will definitely buy more of these buttery lipsticks. NYX has so many shades to chose from and they are reasonably priced to own one too many.

This was something that I wanted for a long time and the reason I finally caved and made an order directly from NYXcosmetics.com using my YouShop account. I purchased this from them for USD$6. I bought the colour Sweet Tart which is a bright-ish reddened pink.

I really like the packaging of this. It doesn't feel expensive but it is incredibly practical. The casing is the shade of the lipstick and in the middle is a clear section where you can see the lipstick itself so you know the exact shade. It feels quite sturdy and I am in no way worried about it breaking at all.

The product itself glides onto the lips effortlessly. I really like the formula as you put it on the lips. Like the name suggests it is buttery! It feels creamy and glossy with no tacky-ness or sticky-ness at all. It doesn't dry my lips out at all. Unfortunately as to be expected with a product like this it does where off as soon as I eat or drink something. To me that isn't particularly a big deal, and is to be expected with this sort of formula.

I'm really glad that I purchased this and can't believe the quality of the NYX products that I have tried so far.

The packing of the lipstick is quite sturdy and beautiful. It comes in a colored plastic bullet which is of the same color as the shade inside. The middle portion of the lipstick is transparent and the shade inside can be clearly seen. I have it in two shades - Taffy and sweet tart. Both of them are different shades of pink (I am a pink lipstick lover).

Taffy is a cool toned light pink, sort of a barbie pink color and looks amazing on the lips. While the shade Sweet Tart is a cool toned deep pink. It is much darker than the taffy shade. The texture of these lipsticks is very buttery. They glide like butter on lips. They look like any other normal lipstick from outside but when they come in contact with the lips, they melt into a very smooth and buttery texture which I love. The lipstick itself is moisturizing on lips, so there is no need of lip balm underneath. The texture gives a feel that the lipstick has sheer coverage but the color is very much build-able.

Because, they have such a buttery texture, I did not expect them to stay for long. But, they last on my lips for almost 4 hours which is good. And when they do fade, they leave a faint stain behind which I really like. It has a caramel kind of sweet smell and the smell is neither overpowering nor long lasting so no issues with the smell. Summing up, if you love buttery and moisturizing lipsticks with awesome color payoff this is a perfect choice for you! :)