Max value reached

Adding this item would put you over your total vault limit of $250. please review your cart to stay under the limit.

Beauty Betrayal: Are celebrity brands picture perfect?

17 March, 2024 - 11:54am by - BR-Queenie | 18 Comments

Are celebrity beauty brands all they're cracked up to be, or is there more beneath the surface? Let's peel back the layers and examine the complexities surrounding the phenomenon of celebrity-backed makeup lines, using the infamous Kylie Jenner Lip Kit scandal as a cautionary tale.

 Fenty Beauty by Rihanna: Breaking Boundaries or Riding the Wave?

While Rihanna's Fenty Beauty is celebrated for its groundbreaking inclusivity, some sceptics question whether it's genuine progress or simply capitalising on a trend. Are celebrity beauty brands truly committed to diversity, or are they merely surfing the wave of social consciousness for profit?

KKW Beauty by Kim Kardashian: Contouring Ethics

Kim Kardashian West's KKW Beauty empire has faced scrutiny for its alleged use of controversial marketing tactics and exaggerated claims. From exaggerated before-and-after photos to accusations of cultural appropriation, the brand's success raises questions about authenticity and integrity in the beauty industry.

Kylie Cosmetics by Kylie Jenner: The Lip Kit Fiasco

The Kylie Jenner Lip Kit scandal serves as a stark reminder of the risks associated with celebrity beauty brands. From quality control issues to customer complaints of allergic reactions, the controversy surrounding Kylie Cosmetics where she plugged the ultimate lip kit to consumers wanting her perfect pout, only to later admit to lip fillers, underscores the importance of transparency and accountability.

Rare Beauty by Selena Gomez: Genuine Empowerment or Marketing Ploy?

Selena Gomez's Rare Beauty is praised for its focus on mental health advocacy and self-expression. However, some critics argue that celebrity-backed initiatives like Rare Beauty may exploit social causes for brand image enhancement, raising questions about authenticity and sincerity.

Haus Laboratories by Lady Gaga: Artistic Expression or Commercialization?

Lady Gaga's Haus Laboratories celebrates individuality and creativity, but is it a genuine reflection of her artistic vision or simply another revenue stream? As celebrities venture into the beauty industry, it's essential to consider whether their brands prioritize artistic integrity or commercial gain.

In light of the Kylie Jenner Lip Kit scandal and other controversies surrounding celebrity beauty brands, it's clear that fame alone does not guarantee quality or ethics. As consumers, we must approach celebrity-backed makeup lines with a critical eye, holding brands accountable for their actions and values.  The celbrities may well approve colours and packaging but will have little to do with personally enforcing product quality and delivery customer service. Ultimately, the true measure of a beauty brand's worth lies not in its celebrity endorsement, but in its commitment to integrity, quality and authenticity.

What are your thoughts? Do you buy celebrity beauty brands? Join the chat below.


Please sign in or register to add a comment.

24th April, 2024

I e never purchased any celebrity makeup brands, there seem to be so many out there it’s kinda hard to tell which ones would get good and which wouldn’t lol

23rd April, 2024

Celebrity endorsed products don't interest me, I like local brands more.

19th April, 2024

Not Interested wether a product is celebrity endorsed or not, if I want or need a product and it's within my price range then I'll just buy it especially if I have had a previous good experience with the brand or product.

17th April, 2024

If celebrities actually donate to the causes they are using to profit from I don't think it's being greedy or bad. With the Kylie lip kits alot if the reactions were from counterfeit products I'm not a Kylie fan I just know because I watched a documentary about knock off cosmetics. I also believe that alot of celebrities get away with using really cheap low quality ingredients and charging alot simply because of who they are.

9th April, 2024

I have bought a few Flower products aka Drew Barrymore though they are at an affordable price. Mco beauty have some Charlotte Tilbury dupes which are good. Maybe I would purchase if it was endorsed by a good make-up artist at a realistic price. I definitely wouldn't buy anything Kardashian to me it's a money grab.

9th April, 2024

Celeb endorsements do nothing for me. Almost makes me not want to buy the product.

3rd April, 2024

Not generally a fan of celebrity endorsed skincare or cosmetics but I do like some celebrity perfumes/colognes.

2nd April, 2024

I do not buy celebrity beauty products. I don't think they are all good or all bad, but surely for the celebrities they are just another income stream.

2nd April, 2024

Definitely not my thing!

28th March, 2024

No I haven’t for years.. just celeb perfume now really

22nd March, 2024

I only buy items if they are good quality for the price and have great reviews. Never buy something just because a celebrity owns the brand.

19th March, 2024

Not a fan in general - I agree with comments below about sticking to brands with expertise. Celebrities are a bit of a gimmick to me!

18th March, 2024

I once did buy Kylie Cosmetics when she first launched her products, it was affordable pricing but it barely lasted me a month and the lip liner broke and the lipstick dried out so quickly. Such a shame

18th March, 2024

I've never bought a celebrity beauty brand and probably never will. I'd rather stick to the specialist companies that research, develop and produce quality skincare and cosmetics.

18th March, 2024

I won’t buy a brand based on the founder but if the reviews are good I will try it. I absolutely love Fenty it seems to work for my skin and complexion. I haven’t tried any of these others brands.

19th March, 2024

Yes a good product is a good product but the celeb doesn't make it better or worse.

19th March, 2024

Yes I totally agree .

19th April, 2024

Same here

19th April, 2024


19th April, 2024

I have brought one or two of her lipsticks which are great and totally affordable.

19th April, 2024

Yep I tend to agree with you here

30th April, 2024

I agree with that. I've heard so much bad stuff about the Kardashians cloning other people's products and selling them as if they came up with the idea!



Sign up to receive our newsletter and stay up to date with all of the latest happenings here at Beauty Review!

You'll be the first to know about Trial Teams, Vault restocks and Giveaways.

We promise never to spam you - only to share the best in NZ beauty!