Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover Review

Lovely little remover found that did leave little bit of residue but when wiped with a clean cotton ball after it removed this.

I purchased this as its cheaper than the one i normally use. And although it does take off all my eye makeup i find i have to rub quite alot for it to remove everything. and even though its oil free, somehow it leaves my eyes feeling quiet oily..? I will use the rest of the bottle but most likely wont re-purchase just because i have another one i prefer.

I have bought this product a couple of times, not because I love it, mostly because I am so undecided about it. I find I have to use a lot of the product to remove my eye make up, also the makeup pads soak up a lot. You definately need to place the make up pad over your eyes & hold for awhile then swipe gently. I have to use a combination of make up pads & cotton buds otherwise I wake up with panda eyes from remaining residue. I really like the texture of the remover, it feels very smooth & silky around the eye once the makeup has been removed, it doesn't sting at all which I am happy about as I have very sensitive eyes. I would prefer the bottle had a small dripper or cap where you could control the amount that was coming out, it would make it a lot easier to use. I think next time around I'll purchase another product to compare, it might help me to decide if this will be a future repurchase.

Don't let the blue bottle fool you, I have never had a makeup remover as amazing as the Neutrogena makeup remover, they do exactly as they say! No makeup remover can remove waterproof mascara or glitter as easily as this , it leaves your skin refreshed and smooth. A big bonus is they have also brought out a range of oil-free makeup wipes which is super easy to take in your weekend bag. You only need a small amount on your cotton pad and its safe and secure screw lid prevents any from spilling if you need to carry it with you. The best makeup remover EVER!

I'm now kicking myself for not buying this sooner. I was so sick of having panda eyes even after using a cleanser that supposedly also removes eye makeup. This stuff is gold, you don't need a lot it doesn't take a lot of rubbing to remove even stubborn mascara. I'm hooked.

This makeup remover is very effective, just a small amount on a cotton pad and one wipe gets most of my eye makeup off - and I go fairly heavy on the gel liner and waterproof mascara. I do find that it leaves an oily feel behind on my skin which I am not a fan of, though it dries up fairly quickly, it does mean that I can't use this to help fix up mistakes as it smears things around and stops me doing anything for a while. I also find that if I leave it too long on the pad it seems to evaporate and I need to pour more.

I wish it wasn't just a screw off cap - as you only use small amounts a squirt bottle or even just a smaller neck for pouring it out would be great. I've lost a fair bit with rushed pours. Frustrating.

This stuff is incredible! It removes any and everything with ease- waterproof, glitter, pigments, if it goes on your eyes it'll remove it.

Also used this to remove foundation that wouldn't budge with cleanser, just be sure to cleanse afterward or it leaves your face slightly oily.

This "oil-free" eye makeup remover left my eyes feeling oily and gross :( it did however get rid of any eye makeup I was wearing but I did not like the feeling it left on my face :/

This one is a great product especially because i use a lot of eyeshadows/liners. It is strong and will take everything off however does not harm or hurt my face in anyway. Great for waterproof mascaras too and seems to remove all remaining product. A little pricey but worth the money.

I found this remover to be quite oily (even though its meant to be oil free) & took a lot of rubbing to remove my eyeliner.