I grabbed this cleanser in the last Beauty Vault, in a continuation of my eternal quest for the perfect daily cleanser. I was grabbed by the "Pore Refining" title, and went ahead with great hopes. Hmmm
It is not a bad product, it leaves my skin nice & clean, and I'm definitely having less breakouts. My pores do not look smaller though. And I spend A LOT of time inspecting my pores. The smell was a bit of a shock a first - a little on the harsh side, but I soon got used to it. It foams up nicely, and leaves my skin feeling clean. But about 5 minutes after my shower, my skin is incredibly dry - it's a bit itchy, tight, and just feels dry. This will be different with all skin types, of course.
I'll possibly buy it again, as I like the less-breakouts side of it, and am yet to find a cleanser that does that for me, without feeling like my skin is being damaged.
I picked this up from the last beauty vault for my boyfriend who has very oily acne prone skin. This was not good for him as it broke him out really bad and did not shrink his pores.
I on the other hand have very dry skin and suffer from eczema not acne. I found this product worked pretty good at removing my make up and left my skin feeling nice and smooth. The tone of my skin did not improve however. This is a pretty average face wash but the most surprising thing is I seem to be allergic to all Neutrogena products as they burn my skin and make it very inflamed, but I didn't have that reaction to this particular cleanser. I find this cleanser to be oddly gentle on my sensitive skin.