I was gifted this for Christmas one year and it served me well until I dropped it and the powder cracked and spilled everywhere!
The colours transfer well from pallet to eyelid with minimal cheek dusting. They last fairly well but are not super pigmented. Works really well as a quad for in the travel kit for between gym & work though!
To break it down packaging first; the eye-like contouring gives it a unique pattern aesthetically, and also gives suggestion to a potential way to use the shadows, although not how I'd use them. It's also a solid quad that doesn't break in my handbag.
In terms of the shadows themselves, the colour pay off is good and they stay pretty much where they are supposed to. They also feel soft and smooth in their application and wear.
I got given these in they bronze smoky quad. But for me personally, I prefer a grey smoky look to a bronze smoky look. However, it still creates an attractive eye look.