Maybelline Eye Studio Gel Eyeliner Review

This is a good gel eyeliner. The texture is creamy, so it glides on easily. I've used the charcoal colour for a less dramatic look (as I am quite pale), and it looks really good. The brush works quite well. The fact that it is flat means you can turn it on its side for a skinny line, or have it flat for a thick line. It's brilliant that the brush is included - great for people that don't own an eyeliner brush.

I persevered with this one but I just couldn't get excited about it.

I found it difficult to apply, potentially due to the brush supplied, and once on it seemed to smudge very easily. Perhaps I would have a better experience with a different brush, but it just seemed a little too hard for me to get used to.

As a disclaimer though, I have been wearing liquid non-stop for years and this has been my first and only experience with a gel formula.

I have used 3 black jars and 2 brown-black ones. This is the eyeliner that changes my perspectives on gel liner. It's smooth and can create various effects: natural, dramatic or edgy. It's my everyday liner. Pros: - good price at great quantity and quality (believe me you would never use it up unless you are a professional) - long lasting - comes with a brush

Cons: - it's not totally water-proof in my opinion, may not last all day long if you have oily skin - the brush is not easy to use for beginners, I think the producers should provide an angled brush instead

I recently got this gel liner after hearing so many good things about it!! I have needed to invest in something that will provide long lasting colour. Hate it when eyeliner fades after only a coupe of hours wear, especially on nights out. I really liked how this came with the eyeliner brush too (although I usually use another brush). It's super soft, and so easy to apply:) The price is pretty good too, the pot lasts for ages.

I recently purchased the Maybelline Studio Eye Gel as I was after a good eyeliner that would actually stay in the waterline of my eyes. I have now used this on quite a few occasions and it certainly stays put. The colour is quite dark so I generally use it in the evening. I found it easy to remove and did not irritate my eyes as many eyeliners do.

With this i find that practice makes perfect, I absolutely freaking love this stuff. I've been searching far and wide for an eyeliner, gel or otherwise, to create a winged eye look that lasts all day and is easy to use, and I bought this stuff on a whim and I'm in love. I literally have nothing bad to say about this. The brush is pretty good too.

Like the title says I kind of have a love hate relationship with this product. The brush it comes with isn't quite thin enough to do thin lines so I only use this eyeliner when I want a very bold look like a Cats Eye. I have blackest black which is really great for evening and darker looks. I do like using it as it is a lot easier to use than eye pencils. However it does dry out quite easy which can make it hard to put on. It also runs quite easily so I wouldn't use it during hot weather. That said it is also really hard to get it off if you can't afford the good eye make up remover. I don't actually know why I like using this product but there is just something about it that I love.

I dont really like gel liners from using this product, it can easily be smudged! (when you want it to stay in place) then the likes of a liquid eyeliner! The brush that comes with this is below average as well, its too big to be able to get a thin liner, mine has dried up so much i cant use it anymore! :(

I bought this as it was on offer, and though it would be good for trying cat-eye eyeliner for the first time. When i bought it I wish I bought a new brush as well - the one that comes with it is really awkwardly shaped to try and get a thin sharp line. It was good for my first few attempts - its easily removed with a make up wipe. It's definitely something I'm looking to replace asap.

Honestly, I am ho-hum about this. I wanted to love it as its actually not a bad price for the amount of product ...but I just found it to dry out really quickly (even though I was vigilant in popping the lid back on) and become quite difficult to use. The brush that comes with it is pretty awful - very hard to create a thin line with it. It smudges and transfers to the top of my lid. Sigh.