I have two of these - 'Invincible red', which is a medium red shade and 'Golden Plum' which is a shimmery peachy nude shade.
Both of these liners boast an incredibly creamy consistency that doesn't drag or skip on your lips whatsoever. They are highly pigmented and need only one pass to fully line your lips. Despite being so creamy they don't slide around your lips or travel during the day.
These are twist up pencils, which are my favourite. The nib of the pencil is the perfect size to be able to create an accurate outline of your lips.
Once applied, these tend to last all day on me and I don't feel the need to take them with me for touch ups. Granted the pigment wears out as time goes on, but I expect that with a lipstick and a lip liner is no different.
I have had these for a few months now and I use the red one every time I wear a red lipstick. Even though the red shade has seen a lot of love, there is still about 1/4 of the pencil left. Because you don't need much these last a long time, and for the price you honestly can't go wrong.
I was gifted this. I had only ever used a pencil liner that needs sharpened. After the first use I quickly fell for this.
The retractable design is simple. When you take the lid off the actual product Looks very slim. When you draw it onto your lips it slides. No dragging the lip skin along with it. You only need one sweep. I find with pencils you go over the line at least once. This doesn't need it.
I particularly like this as the consistency stops bleeding of certain liquid lips products. It's like it blocks it from finding those tiny cracks and running away down them like a slip n slide! Then you see the mess a few hours later after everyone has seen you.
My colour is a nude shade that I can wear with all my lippies. It stays put. It feels nice and isn't drying at all.
The lid stays on easy. The motion of popping the liner up and down is smooth.
Highly recommended these