Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Review

I love this waterproof eyeliner, and the best thing is NO SHARPING REQUIRED, its slick little packaging literally fits into anything, glides on nicely and lasts all day.

No sharpener required, just wind it up and apply. I have this in charcoal and personally I found it stays on all day and then I have to use a oil based eye makeup remover to remove it. The texture seems smooth and I don't have to drag it along the eye rim like some others I have used. The pencil is slim and fits nicely in my makeup bag. It does not have as much product inside the pencil as the ones that need sharpening so it doesn't last as long.

This is the only eyeliner I've used and currently still use, that doesn't smudge. I've tried many different brands and types of eyeliners out there Estee Lauder, Clinique, loreal, maybelline, almay, etc but i always always keep this one in my make up bag for everyday liner.

It can outlast just about any environment. Humid, rain, sweaty hot, cold, you name it. Under extremely hot conditions it can smudge a little over my eyelid if im not wearing eyeshadow but to combat that i just apply a little loose setting powder over it and my eyelid and voila no problems.

I have used this quite a few times and each time I was really disappointed, it just doesn't last. After a few hours it starts to run and is really smudgy under my eyes.. ends up looking like I have dark circles under my eyes. It's pigmented really well and is really dark and goes on nice and smoothly, just wish it would last and not end up all over my eyes!

I have just finished my first ever Revlon Colorstay stick, I love how I can roll it up and down to protect it rather then using a pencil and having to sharpen it all the time, It isn't to ruff around the eye it is a nice a smooth coverage. As it neared to the end of the pencil It became a bit of a hassle and would take more effort to apply...But it was very easy to use and i would recommend this product

I have read some of the other reviews on here about this product not having great staying power, but for me I have never had that problem.

I definitely wouldn't recommend using this on your water line as the thickness of the pencil isn't really wide enough to give proper definition on that part.

I find it good to apply under my eyes, and it is easy to smudge, which is good when I want to create that dark smoky eyed look.

I don't think I will be buying it again however, but for the time being it will do :o)

I find this eye liner great for giving a really bold colour but the ability to draw a very fine line with it. I have this in black and find that the way the tip comes to a rounded point really helps with the application. The pencil is long and thin and you can adjust the tip by twisting the pencil to make it longer or shorter. The colour lasts really well without fading or smudging. Would definitely like to try this in different colours.

I wouldn’t buy this again. It has a very short life span once applied, it’s almost worth not using anything - unless you like the look of black smudges under your eyes!!

I got this a long time ago as I really needed a new eyeliner. I hadn't tried any Revlon eyeliners and a friend spoke very highly of this so following her advice, I purchased it.

This swatches really well on my hand and appeared really pigmented. When I got it home and used it it also appeared to have great pigmentation on my waterline and lower eyelid. However, after about 5 minutes of wearing this my eyes really, really stung and started to water really badly. I washed this off but they were sore for the rest of the day.

This happened every time I have used this for my waterline - so I stopped using it there. It irritates my eyes mildly when I use it on my lower lash line, but it is worth pointing out that my eyes are sensitive.

I found that this was really smudge and didn't have great staying power - whenever I have used this after about three hours it has mostly smudged right off, or over my face. Obviously I don't like this and for that reason I won't purchase it again and I wouldn't recommend it. If you're looking for a pm affordable eyeliner, I'd go th Australis over this.

Glides on smoothly & the colour is good. I have my eyeliner tattooed on (micro pigmentation) but occasionally I use eyeliner on my eyelid to make my eyes pop more, I used this one and after a couple of hours it had smudged up under my eyebrow!! So much for not smearing or smudging!! I had a second eyebrow in black below my actual eyebrow!! Not impressed. But I decided to give it another couple of chances to prove itself & the same thing happened. Only good for lower eyeliner.