This is the first eyebrow kit I have used and I love it I have only ever used pencils before and I'm definitely a eyebrow kit convert.
It doesn't budge during the day stays put and is easy to remove. I brought mine in the colour ash from kmart for $10 and I find it the perfect colour for me not too dark and really natural looking. The packaging is nice a compact with a mirror and small brush that isn't the best but still usable.
The gel side is definitely the best I am a little confused on what the powder side is actually for I did try it and didn't notice what it actually did but I am really happy just buying it for the gel
I got this e.l.f Brow Kit when I lost my ABH Brow Wiz and was in desperate need of something cheap and locally accessible. In that regard it did the job, however, if natural is what your going for I daresay this isn't the product for you as the tinted was tends to lean on the darker side and creates a more 'boxy' brow if precautions aren't taken. That all being said if a very light hand is used this really can't be beaten on price or quality.