I always love a lengthening mascara. Volumising ones don't do enough for my lashes so I need heaps of length. I compare EVERY mascara to my WNW Lash Renegade, and this one disappointed me. It worked great on my right eye since my lashes are nicely placed and also pretty long. But on my left eye it looked awful and the formula is wet so it went everywhere. I had to comb through my lashes with a different wand because too much product was applied even though I was trying not to apply much.
It wore great throughout the day but I then realised I got the waterproof one instead of the normal, which is what it was marked as at Farmers. I don't like waterproof because its hard to take off. I ended up just sleeping with it on and going to work the next day like that because it didn't move on my eyes at all, my eyelashes still looked exactly the same.
I would recommend this mascara if your eyelashes are the same on both eyes but if they're not it will look very weird and you'll have to use two different mascaras.