I love these pencils, they are soft, easy to apply and long wearing. They are smooth but have just enough waxiness to them that they stay put and are great for wearing under glosses and balms.
My shade is Addiction - a nude with an equal balance of brown, pink and mauve. It looks great with all my nude lipsticks and perfect for night time when some of my more beigey brown nude lipsticks wash me out. I have several backups as I love the colour so much.
I love the slanted tip, how affordable these are and the finish. My only dislike is the chemical plastic odour these have but it soon dissipates so I can deal with it.
The packaging of this product is simple, but effective. The lip liner is wound upwards by twisting the bottom and has a tight lid so I don't have to worry about lrogue lids falling off in my make-up bag. I own the shade Pure, which is an incredibly versatile shade as it matches well with several of my pink lippies that are varying shades of pink. I'm a bit of a newbie to lip liners and this lines my lips precisely and I also use it to colour my entire lips in before applying lipstick to enhance the staying powder of my lipstick. This isn't drying and actually moisturizes my lips which makes it perfect for filling in lips and it has helped my lipstick to stay on after eating food, which it never used to without this lip liner. I will repurchase this as it does what it's supposed to do and is very affordable and it is easier for me to use than pencil lip liners.
Tips: Apply chapstick before use to allow the liner to glide on better.