So my lashes are long and pretty good anyway, but my sister started raving about this and i had to see what the big deal was so i bought some myself... my goodness...
Long Thick Fluffy
everything i wanted in lashes...
no clumping and not falking or smudging
worked better than my MAC
Easy to apply and it definitely made my lashes look heaps longer and fuller. Didn't clump too much, nice even coatings. Doesn't smudge or rub off, yet it's still easy to remove. I'm not sure what difference the 'smoky eye' formula makes but wouldn't hesitate to try it especially if you already like the regular one.