I've used this mascara for a long time. Originally I started with the orange one but I found that this one was better as the wand is smaller so it's easier to apply. It makes my eyes look so full when really I don't have much to start with. It's a miracle!
It doesn't flake (which is something I hate) and definitely won't clump. I just love how easy it is to apply. I find the more I add to my lashes the fuller they look (but don't go crazy).
This is my current everyday mascara. It works great, no clumps or lumps and every lash is separated. Goes on easy and has no odour. It holds a curl well as stays in place all day. No crumbling or fall out. If I had to found a fault it doesn't put much volume to the lash. I would buy it again and I have recommended it to friends that are happy with it as well