This eyeliner is fairly good in its own right, but I just don't feel it stacks up to others that are available, especially at that price point.
It's easier to use than liquid, which is great, but I find it not as easy as some other gels/creams (it just seems less smooth) and MUCH harder to get a sharp line with, and then I find that while its staying power is pretty good for the most part, it's not as good as my Stila Smudge Pot and is prone to a little bit of fallout and smudging.
While I won't be buying it again because I just don't feel it's worth the price, I will at least be able to use it up because I've found it's really good at staying put on my waterline for when I'm doing dark smokey looks (and at least then a bit of smudging and fallout isn't noticeable!).
I purchased this 3 weeks and have been using it almost everyday since. It was definitely a splurge buy (it was my birthday and i decided to splurge so i brought a whole heap of high end makep) It was creamy easy to use. I found when trying to apply it over matte or sating eyeshadow it was ok but when i did it over a pigment or glitter it lost pigmentation, i had to build it up. I have oily skin and I think it makes it smuge, I have swatched this on my hand and it wount budge at all, but on my eye it definitly smudges so im going to attribute that to my oily skin, thats my only problem with this product, that and the price which is steep. maybe if i got my oily skin under control i would love it. finger crossed