I did not have very high hopes for this eyeliner since it was SO cheap, and even from more expensive brands I've never had good luck finding a thin-tipped, smudge-proof liner. Was blown away by this one! I've given it 5/5 kisses for a reason!
When this eyeliner says thin tipped, it actually means VERY thin tipped. Thank goodness. So much of the time eyeliners are advertised this way but the tip of the liner ends up actually being huge when you open the product. This one is so thin you could even draw on realistic fake lashes if you wanted to, not to mention nailing that super-fine cat eye.
Product-wise, this eyeliner is very black, doesn't fade throughout the day (even when the weather's hot), literally doesn't smudge, doesn't sting the eyes, basically does absolutely nothing except staying on your face exactly as you applied it. When it comes to removing it though it comes away super easily with makeup remover.
Plus, it's super darn cheap and isn't tested on animals. Holy grail eyeliner, hello.
For $5 I didn't really expect this eyeliner to be much, but boy was I wrong! It is super dark, goes on smoothly, the brush is the perfect shape to get amazing sharp wings, and it stays on all day! I have tried MANY liquid liners and this is up there in my top 5! Everyone should give this underdog a go!