I found this for a dollar or so and thought it was worth a try. The product was smooth to apply which I didn't expect and there was almost more product than I needed. I do my eyeliner quite heavy so for me this was something I was quite happy about. The eyeshadow side didn't quite work for me, a thin pencil as eyeshadow didn't work for me as far as even making sense and this pencil also wasn't a great eyeshadow. I ended up using it as two eyeliners.
I took the dual eyeliner/eyeshadow pencil away with me because I rationalized that it was space saving. However because it is a cheap pencil it also was a bit of a time waster because you had to reapply it if you wanted it to last the day.
The accompanying pencil sharpener wasn't bad quality which is good in a cheap product. I have brought pencil sharpener for more than have lasted less time.
So for a cheap product I think they did alright.
Okay so for a while I went through a "Cheappie" phase and with it being $5 from the warehouse I really couldn't complain. Especially since it came with its own pencil sharpener!! Mine came with one black end (eyeliner) and a grey/silver end (eyeshadow) and I praise the eyeliner side. It glides on smoothly as well as smudges so easily. Like with some eyeliners ive tried they dry before I get a chance to smudge whereas this one doesn't. It does cause panda eyes though. Like when you blink too often it will transfer to your lower lash line. The eyeshadow on the other hand is a waste of a pencil. completely useless. Its a thick and gross texture, doesn't glide easily. Doesn't smudge or blend easily. Complete waste. The pencil sharpener was good, The blade was sharp and sharpened both the pencil and other brand pencils. Definitely worth spending the $5 on if you're into the black eye (smudge look).