I usually use a liquid liner, so this was a fun trial.
Pros: - The packaging is what you'd expect, but the lid is strong and stays on, great for in the makeup bag. - The pencil can be sharpened - The pencil is not bitty or chalky, nor does it feel dry. - It's easy to do a basic flick, or a full wing. - It reallllllllllly lasts - you could sleep in this and wake up with the perfect cat's eye.
Cons: - REALLY hard to remove. You either need a good waterproof-makeup remover, or settling in for a good amount of cleansing and re-cleansing. - Does not come with a built-in sharpener in the lid. This should be mandatory on all eye pencils!
Holy smokes, when they say 36 hour finish you better believe it!
This eyeliner just glides, it's very smooth and relatively easy to get the feel of quite quickly. Keep some makeup remover wipes, or micellar-saturated pads handy, you'll need to be quick to remove it without smudging if you do make a boo boo.
This is quite possibly the best eyeliner I've used, it's all of the pros of a liquid liner in a pencil form.
It does remove with an oil cleanser or eye-makeup remover, so don't worry you won't be rocking panda eyes post-shower.
Top Marks Maybelline!