Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover Review

This was my first ever eye makeup remover and I found it to be highly effective. I do find that I like to cleanse after it as I do find that it leaves a bit of an oily residue. It easily removes liquid eyeliner and waterproof mascara which is always a pain to get off. It doesn't hurt or dry out the skin around my eyes so its a lovely product, I have since moved on to Micellar waters as they don't leave that 'oily/ residue.

I found the Neutrogena Oil-Free makeup remover to be a good mid-range product - it does what is says it will do for a very reasonable price so what more can you really ask for?! The smell is a bit chemically but in all honesty, unless you're taking a big whiff of it I don't see how that would really bother you. It removed my makeup easily (although I never wear waterproof mascara so have no idea how it would go with that) and it didn't sting my eyes (many others have). Despite it saying on the bottle "leaves no oily residue" it did still leave an oily film around my eyes, but no worse than any other makeup remover I've tried. All in all, a good solid product.

Comparing this other make up removers it is not as good, however for the price it is very good. it gets off all water proof make up but i dont like the feeling it gives after removing on my skin.

I have used this in the past and found that it was useful and worked well but when it ran out I then just used my face wash as it had a make-up remover built in and saved my pennies for something else

I brought this because it was "oil free" - it does a great job of taking off my stubborn water proof eye makeup but it is so oily!

It leaves this horrible oily film on my face and I feel like I need to go and re wash my face to take it off.

I can't decide what my final verdict is on this one - it's the best I have used for taking off all of my makeup without leaving that shadow effect from the mascara but I really don't like the oiliness of it..

I'm not too sure about this product. It says its Oil Free but the product in the bottle looks oily? It didn't get all of my eye makeup off but I would use it again as it did do a good job, just not fantastic!

This used to be my absolute, HG, always-had-a-spare-waiting product for removing mascara. I have since found something much better, but would recommend this to anyone on a budget or in a pickle (like, you NEED some remover right now and all you have access to is a supermarket).

This product does remove makeup, and doesn't need scrubbing and rubbing ,but it leaves a residue and doesn't do anything for lash growth. It does the trick, but there are better products out there.

I was quite impressed with this product. I always find eye make-up removers sting my eyes and leave them very saw and itchy or very oily and heavy. this left my eyes feeling fresh and clean was impressed I don't use waterproof makeup so that may be a bit harder to remove but for normal make-up eye liner ect it was great. I found it works best with cotton pads over straight cotton. doesn't get absorbed as much. over all good product does what it says on the bottle.

Love this basic and recent addition to my cabinet. It's just a teeny weeny a bit too oily for my liking but for how affordable it is I can't complain! It definitely does a good job at removing all makeup.

Really great for removing stubborn eye make up, though you do have to rest the cotton soaked pad on your eye for a while (10sec minimum) to have it truly wipe everything away. The only issue I have had in using this product is the 'non oily' claims, I don't think that I am using too much of the product, but I always feel like I have bathed my eye area in a vat of oil after use! This is easily taken care of by then washing my face again, however it is a bit of a let down.