I really love this product!
Having also previously tried the Garnier BB Cream for Normal skin, I was surprised to see how different the two formulations are.
For a start, the texture is completely different - the Normal formulation is thick and quite gluggy, whereas the Oil-Free formula is very light and goes on much more smoothly. I found that this meant I could put a thin layer all over my face, then build up additional coverage where I needed it, without it getting too orange/patchy/thick looking.
The tone is also quite different - I found I had to be careful with the Normal skin version in 'light' because it actually wasn't that light and could make me look orange if I applied too much. In contrast, the 'light' Oil-Free version is a great colour for my pale freckly skin. It gives me a healthy golden glow without looking fake, and does a great job of covering freckles, redness and that purply translucent skin around the eyes when I'm tired!
And finally the matte finish is very different - the Normal skin version made me look very shiny, whereas the Oil-Free one is great at keeping me shine-free.
I have been wearing this product alone, in place of a foundation, and find it gives plenty of coverage and stays put for a day in the office. I would reapply to go out at night, but I would do that with a foundation anyway, so was really impressed with the coverage and staying power for a lighter product.
Does it do what it says? On the whole, yes. It definitely gives skin an even tone, a healthy glow and a nice matte finish, and the SPF 15 is a good inclusion for NZ too. I'm not 100% convinced that it would reduce the size of pores, that seems like a big claim, but maybe if I keep using it for longer, that will come true... fingers crossed!
Overall, I've found this product really great, and will definitely keep using it, for a fuss-free, oil-free everyday makeup product that is actually doing my skin some good.
I'm absolutely loving this bb cream so far. It concealed most of my blemishes, smoothed out my skin, covered my redness and made my skin look healthier and it didn't make my skin look like I had put my face in a bowl of oil like my current bb cream does. I didn't even have to moisturise or use a primer before applying the bb cream and I still got wonderful results. Overall I would rate this an 8/10. The reasons why it's only an 8 is because the product is too runny for my liking, as soon as I opened it, it dripped onto some important documents of mine and because it sets too quickly it makes it a lot harder to blend it out properly.. I would recommend that you only apply the bb cream to one area of the face at a time to get the best results.