Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Review

Glides on smoothly & the colour is good. I have my eyeliner tattooed on (micro pigmentation) but occasionally I use eyeliner on my eyelid to make my eyes pop more, I used this one and after a couple of hours it had smudged up under my eyebrow!! So much for not smearing or smudging!! I had a second eyebrow in black below my actual eyebrow!! Not impressed. But I decided to give it another couple of chances to prove itself & the same thing happened. Only good for lower eyeliner.

For some reason, highschool days seem to be when the emo eyeliner look comes out. During highschool, this eyeliner was my holy grail. The convenience of having a twist up pencil was great as I could take it anywhere with me and not have to worry about bringing a pencil sharpener with me. The lasting power of this eyeliner is quite good, however on the waterline, it doesn't hold too well. I think this is a great product and I would repurchase in the future to keep for on-the-go touch ups.

No sharpener required, just wind it up and apply. I have this in charcoal and personally I found it stays on all day and then I have to use a oil based eye makeup remover to remove it. The texture seems smooth and I don't have to drag it along the eye rim like some others I have used. The pencil is slim and fits nicely in my makeup bag. It does not have as much product inside the pencil as the ones that need sharpening so it doesn't last as long.

When I regularly tightlined my lids with a twist up rectractible this was one of the ones I tried because I was on the hunt for one that was actually smudge proof for my lash line and water line. It did give a good amount of black pigment but it would always smudge within about half an hour or sooner if it was hot. Carrying Q-tips was a must because I needed them so often. I wouldn't repurchase this or recommend it. It's pretty expensive for something that smudges so quickly unless that's the look you want.

This is super black and glides on nicely, it does stay longer on my water line than most other pencil liners, but to be honest that's not an impressively long time. I do like it but I think I will try something else when I am finished with this. It's not a staple for me.

I tried this product but I can't say it's my fav. I have found much better ones. But it does the job.

I got this a long time ago as I really needed a new eyeliner. I hadn't tried any Revlon eyeliners and a friend spoke very highly of this so following her advice, I purchased it.

This swatches really well on my hand and appeared really pigmented. When I got it home and used it it also appeared to have great pigmentation on my waterline and lower eyelid. However, after about 5 minutes of wearing this my eyes really, really stung and started to water really badly. I washed this off but they were sore for the rest of the day.

This happened every time I have used this for my waterline - so I stopped using it there. It irritates my eyes mildly when I use it on my lower lash line, but it is worth pointing out that my eyes are sensitive.

I found that this was really smudge and didn't have great staying power - whenever I have used this after about three hours it has mostly smudged right off, or over my face. Obviously I don't like this and for that reason I won't purchase it again and I wouldn't recommend it. If you're looking for a pm affordable eyeliner, I'd go th Australis over this.

This is an eyeliner I used in black for a couple of years and found it to be good, if not a bit standard. Application is easy, smooth and gives a medium/thick line. My only criticisms are that I would have to disagree with the claims that it lasts up to 16 hours as I never got anywhere near that and although it looks great immediately after application, it does have a tendency to smudge a wee bit but otherwise, no major issues. The retractable twist design doesn't particularly bother me but I reckon you do get more bang for your buck with a pencil eyeliner. I've since switched to a different brand pencil eyeliner in a brown shade which is better suited to me but I still have my trusty old Colorstay as backup!

This eyeliner is the best I've ever used, there is no other for me that comes close. I don't know why but it works so well. The pencil twists up so no sharpening involved and it lasts for ages as well. Real value for money If you want a sharp line in the corner you get one, if you want smudgy cats eyes, no problem, if you want wings easy peasy. It even has even got a smudged and a sharpener on the end. And it lasts the whole day and night!! and washes off easily with makeup remover. I would buy it again and again like I have done since I found it

i really like this eyeliner, it has to be one of my favs and its not too expensive either. some eyeliners smudge and dont hold but this one stays in place all day