e.l.f Liquid Eyeliner Review

I bought this liquid eyeliner a while ago and have probably only used it two or three times in the 6 months or so that I have had it.

The worst thing about this lliner in my opinion is the brush, it's really hard to get a nice line because the brush is too long and thin. It bends too much when applying so it is almost impossible to get a nice clean line.

It is long lasting and smudge proof so if you apply it and don't do a fantastic job, it's best to get a cotton bud onto it quickly before it sets.

I think the pigmentation is dark enough, the only reason I have had to go over my application is because the brush is too thin so the line isn't bold enough. I counteract this by using my eyeliner brush to sweep it along and make a thicker line as soon as I have applied it.

For the price the product is actually pretty good; I wouldn't expect top of the line quality at this price.

Elf eyeliner is awesome I picked it up for $1 at eyeslipsface.com during their half price sale! I use this liner to create the perfect winged liner look! The product glides on smooth and does not need to be re applied! The liner does not have a noticeable fragrance which I like as this can be quite off putting.

I would recommend this eyeliner for anyone on a budget looking to pick up a good quality product! The bottle is rather small but tends to last a while and for $1 I am not complaining!

This product is a really good price and the quality is pretty good as well.

The black liner itself is really pigmented and leaves a lovely smooth black line which lasts me all night (don't have any worries about it rubbing off). It is also really easy to get off at the end of the night which is great for me because I have quite sensitive eyes.

The brush started off lovely and fine tipped, but after a couple of uses some of the bristles started to stick out at odd angles. This made applying a fine line very difficult because these little bristles left black marks on my lids.

I think this liquid eyeliner is great for anyone who is trialling how they like liquid eyeliner, but since I found the brush didn't stay fine like it should of, I wouldn't call this my holy grail.

I love this eyeliner the wand/applicator is so thin and gets into the inner corners of your eyes. One of the liquid liners that don't smudge throughout the day as i have oily skin. This is definitely my go to liner I use it everyday and i will repurchase as its cheap/affordable. If i want a thin liner for the day its perfect and just build the thickness you like.

I usually love ELF products but this liquid eyeliner was a huge miss for me. It's a bit transparent for my liking and it takes so long to dry that you end up smudging it everywhere. Granted I'm not the best at applying liquid eyeliner but every time I've used this I've ended up with eyeliner all over my hands and sometimes even nose which doesn't happen with other brands. I will not be purchasing this again.

This is a great liquid liner for the price. I've tried others in the drugstore category but keep going back to this one.

I have the black and also brown which I use daily. I like the thin applicator it makes it really easy to get a thin precise line and wing. It is quiet a watery formula but dries well and fast.

Its not as opaque as i would like but it is easily buildable so that not really a big issue. I find that it does fade slightly after a few hours. If i have it on me i will just reapply it but its what i would expect for a product this cheap. I find it doesnt smudge at all which is quiet impressive.

i do really like this and will keep purchasing until i find something better. It definitely does the job well and is amazing for the price. I would recommend this to anyone who doesn't want to fork out a ton of money and just wants something reliable for daily wear.

I've never been one to use liquid eyeliner as A) I cant draw straight lines and B) the liquid always gets in my eyes and hurts! So I bought this one as a cheat trial, and its fantastic! It has a super fine tip (perhaps too fine for me sometimes, so I need multiple layers) and excellent pigment. It also dries quickly and I haven't had any problems with creasing or smudging (with a good primer base). And no sensitivity problems! Would definitely reccommend!

I bought a three pack of these liners on IHerb for only $3 and considering the cost, they are incredible products. However, if I was to ignore the bargain factor I would like to point out a few issues.

I got a plain black, a gold glitter and a silver glitter liner in the pack. The black liner is very watery and it's quite hard to build into a solid line. To remedy this I had to fill in the line with another liquid eyeliner by Coral Colours - luckily both are matte black so they blended well. I'd also say that the glitter in the gold and silver liners should be a little finer, as I think that would look better on the lid. Those are the only 'cons' that I could see, and they're pretty minimal in the grand scheme of things. There are far more things to love about the product than there are to loathe!

The applicator wands are amazing, I wish all liners were made this way. The black liner has a very fine pin point brush that makes it easy to create a variety of liner looks! Usually I find it hard to get a precision line with most liquid liners as they have a felt tip style applicator - but not the e.l.f liner! It is really awesome :) I found that it was great for creating wings and drawing the eyeliner outline, which I then filled in with a 'felt tip style' liquid eyeliner. Even though I need to use two different products, I think the overal effect is worth it.

I also found that I could line my eye with the black and then put an overcoat of gold or silver liner on top without making the undercoat run. This meant I could create some really striking eye looks!

In terms of wearability, these liners stay put all day! They may be watery when first applied, but once they dry they're there to stay. Best of all, they are as easy to put on as they are to take off! Just wipe with a cloth and they're gone, no panda eyes afterwards. These benefits, along with the price, make this a product worth trying

I bought this for like, $3 or $5 on iherb. I'm not big on liquid eyeliner, or eyeliner at all because I'm such a special person when it comes to something so delicate like this.

I like the look of the bottle. It's nice. Black, sleek, and just appealing. The brush and handle sits in the hand nicely for easy application. However, that's where the good stops for me.

Managed to put some on my eyelid, but as I said, I'm not very good so obviously its not perfect, and I'm just playing around with it. Then I feel a burning sensation and I look at my eye - its completely black, including the white of my eye. Somehow, this wonderful product has slipped through my lashes and into my eyeball, making me look like some creature you'd find in a video game. And this was just with one or two flicks after I wiped the brush on the bottle.

So I'm standing in my bathroom mirror, admiring my new eye, because lets face it, it looks pretty cool, but can't be that good for the eye. I get some jojoba oil on some toilet paper to wipe the eyeliner off and I rinse my eye and blink furiously to get the black ink out. The eyeliner came off easily enough but I looked like I had raccoon eyes for the first few wipes of the oil.

Overall, I wouldn't purchase again. I may use it again just to play around but I don't really think my eyes appreciated their mini makeover, so maybe not!

I recently bought this accidently in the shade "Midnight" at my local Kmart.. and even though I thought I was getting a black liner (obviously wasn't looking that well) and getting over the initial disappointment of a navy liner.. I was thoroughly impressed.

The applicator is nice and fine, sturdy and strong, so gives a perfect thin line. The product itself is quite fluid. Not as thick as some liners that I've used but it gives a good coverage and doesn't need to be layered again and again to get the density of colour you want.

I would definitely buy this product again, I've actually just purchased a Black one off iHerb and can't wait for it to arrive.