Vault

Max value reached

Adding this item would put you over your total vault limit of $250. please review your cart to stay under the limit.

Welcome to

Beauty Review

Want to be advised of trial teams we’re running, giveaways, great beauty offers and competitions? Sign up to receive our newsletter now, it’s easy.

The Beauty Vault - Aug
The Beauty Vault - Aug

reviews - is this meant to happen?

36 posts, 14 members
  Author Message  
  trudijoy
REVIEW EXPERT
(6154 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
Just placed a trial review and it went through fine the first time, but as the wee box is hard to edit in i missed a couple of typos. I edited them and despite the fact that the review was there initially it vanished when I edited it.

Hopefully it's still there!
  worldofsooziewong
REVIEW EXPERT
(1857 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
If you edit any review after you've submitted it, it will then go to moderation. Best to email the crew about this as I think they go to the back of the queue or get lost amongst other one s somehow. This happened to me when I edited some before.  
  trudijoy
REVIEW EXPERT
(6154 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
ahhh..... i still have the points so it must be there SOMEWHERE


ETA but yeah good point soozie, have emailed and also suggested they add a preview function to the review portal
  trudijoy
REVIEW EXPERT
(6154 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
Everyone’s reviews for these seem to have vanished, as has the product from the database....?? Huh? Reviews all due today too; this is odd
  shazatron101
REVIEW EXPERT
(3307 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
I thought the same, they gone byebyes
  worldofsooziewong
REVIEW EXPERT
(1857 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
Yeap, even when I found find them in the search bar, it redirected me to the home page. 
  trudijoy
REVIEW EXPERT
(6154 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
so strange. I knew you'd done yours, Shaz, because I read it once I had posted mine, but there are none there now!
  Silvene
REVIEW EXPERT
(749 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
I thought that maybe this was a new feature ... that trial team reviews will only be visible once the deadline is reached, to prevent any “lazy” trial team members from abusing the system by copying and pasting bits from other members reviews, instead of having to actually write their own honest review.  

If so, I think it’s great that the trial product reviews are held back and only released after the deadline, as I did have a issue in the past with someone (who is no longer a BR member) copying and pasting bits of other people’s reviews in order to make up her “own” review, instead of actually trialling the products she was sent. So sad when people are in it just for freebies. 
  trudijoy
REVIEW EXPERT
(6154 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
silvene - I wrote my review on Tuesday and until I'd submitted it I couldn't see the others, then I could see Shaz' (the only other one there at that stage) even after i sent mine back for editing, and could see them again later in the week, but they're all gone now regardless of if you've done your review.

I agree it's a great idea to avoid lazy reviewing (that wasn't why I was looking for them though) but seems wholly bizarre that they're not visible to those who HAVE reviewed them!
  Lisa-Lou
REVIEW EXPERT
(626 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
The same thing happened with the hair care trial I just did. I agree Silvene! I also find it odd when a review has been written and my trial item hasn't even arrived yet. Surely it takes more than 1 day before you can review an item.
  trudijoy
REVIEW EXPERT
(6154 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
Lisa I 100% agree and am often scratching my head as to how these people have PROPERLY trialled something.

I was super time poor when my last one arrived and I had to go away for the rest of the week so I ran four seperate tests on it THAT DAY to be able to write my trial. That's not always going to be possible though and a day-after review is not my usual style!

I think the review i did write is very comprehensive and wouldn't have changed with more time, but i'd have liked more time none the less.
  trudijoy
REVIEW EXPERT
(6154 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
i've noticed the number of products got smaller this arvo too, only by a couple of items but super confusing.
  shazatron101
REVIEW EXPERT
(3307 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
As long as i dont have to write it again i dont care where it went hahahaha. Though i will if i have to :-D
  tannygirl
REVIEW EXPERT
(2809 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
   I submitted my review on Friday night on the Manuka Infused wipes and it disappeared. Can't find the product under the listing and today's the deadline. The notice has disappeared from my inbox though.
  worldofsooziewong
REVIEW EXPERT
(1857 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
Something strange is definitely going on. I just had the (non-trial) review I wrote today approved by a moderator. When I looked on my beauty space to see if my trial review was there, I noticed a review I wrote last month has disappeared (although the product is still on the database). 

Im just assuming it's to do with the exciting new changes that are happening in the background. 
  trudijoy
REVIEW EXPERT
(6154 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
Yeah four I wrote this arvo are there but still not the trial one. Where’s an explanatory pixie, lady or queen when I’m confused? :p
  Helibabi
REVIEW EXPERT
(23 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
Ahhhhhh ok cool I'm glad I'm not the only one who edited a review and had it disappear thought it must still be waiting approval or something but wasn't too sure. When they said they were working away behind the scenes making some changes I thought it might be related to that. Oh well I'm trying to get my grammar perfecto in the mean time so I don't have to edit. 
  Head Pixie
(471 posts)
  • edit post
Morning all!

Right... so... as per Queenie's note the other day, we are working on a number of exciting new developments (like, seriously exciting) so things may appear slightly different for a while. If you see something out of the ordinary then that'll be why. There's a method in the madness, but we can't reveal the method... yet.

If you've written a review on a trial product and submitted it the usual way then it's captured in the system and definitely there. Again, method, madness, can't say much... yet.

Ooooh, don't you love a bit of intrigue on a Monday!?

xx Pix
  tannygirl
REVIEW EXPERT
(2809 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
  Thank you Head Pixie. 
  shazatron101
REVIEW EXPERT
(3307 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
Welcome back pixie!!!! :-D
  Macs
REVIEW EXPERT
(5040 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
Yes I did . Wonder what it is ..
  trudijoy
REVIEW EXPERT
(6154 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
haha methods,,madness, and a Monday that involved me delivering a trophy.

is it wine o'clock yet? :p
  SandyGedge
REVIEW EXPERT
(391 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
Ooh that sounds exciting and intriguing Head Pixie ;-)
  Imoshen
REVIEW EXPERT
(428 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
Trudi - it is ALWAYS wine o'clock (at least somewhere in the world, may as well celebrate it with them)  ;)
  trudijoy
REVIEW EXPERT
(6154 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
possibly not before 9am on a workday lol.

But yeah my nana always used to say 'it's 4.30 somewhere!' (she was a big fan of a the 'half past foursies')
  trudijoy
REVIEW EXPERT
(6154 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
they're baaaaaaaack.

and i found a couple of typos in mine but don't want to fix them and have it vanish again lol
  tannygirl
REVIEW EXPERT
(2809 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
   Yes! My review on the wipes is back and in the order that I submitted reviews.
  shazatron101
REVIEW EXPERT
(3307 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
so i know changes going on yada yada yada, but i see heaps of "new" l'oreal products are being added, but i know i've reviewed some of them, like the black and purple shampoo set and my reviews are still there...
what is going on!!!! is this the upside down!?
i would review them again but i can't even remember what i thought of them the first time round so it'd be a waste of time really but i am hella confused!
  Julieal
REVIEW EXPERT
(816 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
I like the fact that you updatre the system reqularly and I have noticed my review doesn't show until after audited which seems sensible.
  First Lady
(784 posts)
moderator
  • edit post
All will be revealed my precious.
  trudijoy
REVIEW EXPERT
(6154 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
I read that in a Gollum voice lol

Gorgeous SHAZ and NAT: you don’t resemble Gollum. I’m just in a random mood
  shazatron101
REVIEW EXPERT
(3307 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
Mon chou-fleur!!!
I assumed it was all to do with the new thangs but yknow. Curiosity and all that
  trudijoy
REVIEW EXPERT
(6154 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
Chou-fleur!!!! J’adore that phrasing lol
  shazatron101
REVIEW EXPERT
(3307 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
Wheeeeeen is the reevveeaaaallll tell us whats going ooooonnnnn
  trudijoy
REVIEW EXPERT
(6154 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
^^ +1
  Mumof3Munchkins
REVIEW EXPERT
(2375 posts)
REVIEW EXPERT
  • edit post
He he he I noticed this too but as long as I've written my review within the deadline, I don't worry about it too much.

Sounds super exciting Head Pixie (by the way your profile picture is gorgeous xx).

Can't wait to see what you have in store eek x

New?

to find out why you
should join New Zealand's largest beauty website

Click here

Beauty Poll

See all
Does your foundation last all day?

Does your foundation last all day?

No, I have to touch up at least once during the day!

view results

Review of the Day
dani7331
Gentle Gel
I really like this gel cleanser. I have always been a fan of the Micellar water, so it was exciting to try something… more »