I bought the waterproof version of this. Have repurchased twice, it’s that good. It delivers all these claims for me: “lashes are never stiff or brittle. Perfect for everyday wear... safe for contact lens wearers”.
I love how it makes my thin and straight lashes look fuller and curlier (when used with eyelash curler - I haven’t tried it without’.
It doesn’t smudge even after a very long day, really long lasting. Need an oil based makeup remover to remove it properly.
The only thing I find annoying, is the first few times of using it, the wand always picks up too much masacara. To get the best result I need to wipe the wand to the edge of the container, getting rid of the extra amount. Sometimes it feels tedious, but once it has been used a few times, I have no problems with it. This is a minor thing compared to the rest of the positives. Definitely repurchasing more!