I got this pencil in black, and it is currently my go-to for applying to my lower lids. It's smooth and glides on easily. It's able to be blended out quickly for a less-defined look. It stays on all day, and stays put.
The automatic pencil is retractable, so that I don't risk damaging the stick with the lid when recapping.
Also, this product is super cheap at only a few dollars. I will definitely buy this again.
So so so great for the price! It glides on super well due to the creamy texture of the product, and stays on for the duration of the day. I find that its perfect for smudging out (as it blends easily too) if you like the smokey eye look. Definitely recommend.