Max value reached

Adding this item would put you over your total vault limit of $250. please review your cart to stay under the limit.

Welcome to

Beauty Review

Want to be advised of trial teams we’re running, giveaways, great beauty offers and competitions? Sign up to receive our newsletter now, it’s easy.

Dumpster Diving for Makeup - Is it EVER ok?!

8 March, 2018 - 08:57pm by - Head Pixie | 22 Comments

By BR Amelia

How do you get your hands on makeup? Are you one for a touch of online shopping? Are you a fan of going into stores, testing, trying, then buying what captures your interest? Or do you prefer to hang around the back of shops, waiting for night to fall, then diving into their dumpster to see what goodies may have been chucked out during the day?

Yes, I know that last way of procuring cosmetics sounds rather extrame, but it's a thing. Not only is it a thing, but for some people it's big business.

Dumpster diving makeup hauls aren't some flash in the pan trend, they've been going on for a while now, in fact our own members were talking about it two years ago - with the overwhelming response being that it was a big 'no' for them. Yet, one quick look at YouTube shows that the concept is continuing to flourish, with YouTubers uploading their finds on a regular basis.

When I first heard about it I imagined these people were pulling open rubbish bags to find testers and returned goods that had been tossed aside. Except, that's not what happens. Companies in the United States make a huge effort to ensure the products they throw out are unusable. The dumpster divers open up bags to find the products covered in foundation, shampoo, conditioner. Lines (presumably created by using scizzors, box cutters or keys) are run through eyeshadows, highlighters and powders. Perfumes have their lids and nozzles removed. And yet the contents are pawed through, checked over, with products being put in the 'too destroyed to do anything with' pile, or the 'saved' pile.

Yes, these people believe the expired and returned products can be saved. And not just for their own use. In one video the woman set aside the products she'd be keeping for herself, and the ones she would be selling. SELLING.

Now, I'm all for recycling, reusing and repurposing. If I have a lightly used and unexpired eyeshadow palette I will sanitise it and pass it on to a family member telling them I've used it - but because they know me, trust me and I can guarantee I haven't had an eye infection, they're okay with it. Would they take a product from a complete stranger? No. 

Yet this is what people may well be unknowingly doing when they buy a 'makeup haul' off an auction site or Facebook group.

Let's think about this for a second. Products testers have been swatched and touched by who knows how many people. People you don't know. People who could have infections of some kind. Returned goods may still look brand new having only been used once or twice, but again, they carry the risk of stranger danger. Not only that, but the products have been sitting in a rubbish bin for who knows how long? 

Anyone else remember doing that petri dish bacteria test in high school? We put our petri dish in a rubbish bin for one minute - you won't believe the blooms that grew on the agar gel. It was disturbing stuff. Yet people are scavenging products, then either using them on their faces, or selling them online - and you can't tell me that they disclose where they got it from. My search of ebay showed no mention whatsoever of where the used makeup had come from. No surprises there...

So it is happening in New Zealand? We spoke to Moyra Parker, General Manager of Makeup Direct, and asked if they'd experienced dumpster diving, but she was unaware of anyone going through their rubbish. However at Makeup Direct they do try to minimize waste as much as possible by offering any damaged (i.e. broken lid) or near expiring products to their purchasing customers for free when they have made a purchase (with full disclosure that it is damaged or near expiring). It's also offered to staff or family and friends. They have also donated such product to local schools for their drama/productions and a women’s organisation (again with full disclosure they are damaged or near expiring).  

Moyra's advice to people who might consider going through a company’s rubbish in order to take home product? Unsurprisingly, don't do it. "They are putting their own health and safety at risk – glass, chemicals etc," she said. "You also don’t really have any knowledge as to why the products have been disposed of.  I certainly think it is wrong if you dumpster dive for a profit (i.e. sell online) – this could possibly cause so many other problems down the track not only to the dumpster diver but also to the buyer, the company/brand …lawsuits if anything happens to them, such as an electrical fault on a faulty hairdryer."

We say no to dumpster diving. The beauty industry says no to dumpster diving. What say you? Would you do it? Would you buy products that came from a dumpster diving expedition? Or is it a big NO from you too? Chat away!

View previous polls

Please sign in or register to add a comment.

Definate no from me, I have to many health issues already I can't imagine getting things this way would be of any benefit and a bad idea

Hey chick flick me a message though facebook if you like

16th March, 2018 at 12:14 am

I mean I want to tell you something other wise all good up to you

16th March, 2018 at 12:18 am

Erm no dumpster diving. I love the idea of giving damaged/expired products to groups though, I bet woman's refuge would love to receive some of those things, and deodorants, powders, hairbrushes etc.

really good idea MareeB

9th March, 2018 at 7:27 am

Oh what a shocker to read! Can't believe people would sell something they find in the rubbish, wtf??? Also it's nice to hear that Makeup Direct give it out for free, as it should be, why waste it if someone can use it for another diy purpose!

Ummm eww a big NO from me! Gross and disgusting.

NO Dumpster diving -I like Make up Direct's idea of either giving to staff and friends with acknowledgement that is has been opened or expired.

Yeah this is just too gross for me, would rather go without makeup than do something that extreme. Great to hear that Makeup Direct doesn't just chuck their old makeup - I know a lot of pharmacies offer their soon-expiring products to staff as well.

I am fascinated in general with goods hauls that get thrown out and people then retriece. I can't say that I would ever it and onselling it from a dumpster is wrong. I haven't heard of it happening in NZ but that's not to say it doesn't happen. Passing products on to groups and family or friends seems like a better idea.

Me too - I've watched the shows where people raid dumpsters for food. They don't do too badly either, but it'd take a bit of bravery I think.

9th March, 2018 at 6:29 pm

The food ones i'm like most definitely not but have also seem gaming ones as well. They do really well.

10th March, 2018 at 9:10 pm

Never heard of it, but its a no for me

I’ve seen it before in America you tube. Never here though

Ah big no.

And it's a NO from me. Eurgch!!!

I've heard of dumpster diving for makeup and stuff. I agree it's very unethical to sell makeup you got from the trash. I've only bought a few makeup products off ebay and brand new limited editions so I don't think they were salvaged from the garbage. I would never unknowingly purchased makeup or beauty products that were gotten from the trash. Another reason to cut your tubes and bottles in half to get out the last bit of product but also so dumpster divers can't take the bottles and tubes and fill them up with another sunscreen or cheap lotion and sell the bottle or tube.

No dumpster diving! Would give unwanted/unsuitable items to others though

Definitely a big no from me! I've never heard of anyone doing this, but surely it would occur to them it's not very hygienic. Just gross! I can't believe people do this!


to find out why you
should join New Zealand's largest beauty website

Click here

Beauty Poll

See all
Do You Need Gentle but EFFECTIVE Skincare?

Do You Need Gentle but EFFECTIVE Skincare?

Yes, my skin is sensitive but troubled...

view results

Review of the Day
Amazing regime
Love these two products!! Hair is hydrated which is something I’ve always struggled with in winter.… more »