I have combination/oily skin, mostly leaning towards oily with large pores, and occasional dry flaky patches.
I have quite a few foundations -- something like eight currently! Most of them are liquids or cream compacts, so I was keen to try out a stick formula. I'm currently approximately an NC30 in MAC shades, and went for 220 and 235. These two are actually pretty similar in tone, but the 220 has pinker undertones, and the 235 slightly more golden. Both work on me because it's fairly sheer in coverage -- I'd say light to medium, and it doesn't look very good if you try and build to more than that because it starts caking up.
It has a bit of a cooling sensation when you swipe it on your skin. I put one swipe each across my forehead, down my nose, on my cheeks and a dab on my chin. I've used my fingers and the Real Techniques buffing brush, and both work well. It settles into pores slightly, but evens out if you buff it in.
There's only 9g of product, which doesn't seem like a lot in comparison to most liquid foundations which contain 30mls -- it's hard to tell so far, but I'll update once I've used it a while to see how long it might last.
I would describe the finish as satin; not matte and not dewy. It's quite emollient, and there's a bit of a tacky feeling if you have built it up; I find that I want to set it with powder after I apply it. Despite the "Shine-Free" description in the name, I don't find that it has any oil control properties, so you may want to use a mattifying primer or an oil-control product if you are really oily. I also find that it can cling to flaky patches, like dry bits around healing blemishes. There is some minor transfer if you rub against clothing etc.
The packaging is pretty compact and it's ideal for reapplication if you're on the go -- it's actually why I got two, so I can keep one in my gym bag and one at home.
I think this would work really well as a cream contour, as I find it pretty easy to blend out. I think I'd go for 330 -- 310 actually seems very similar in tone to 220 and 235, just pinker.
I would probably only recommend it if you have normal to slightly oily/combo skins. It's perfect for evening out your skintone, but not really ideal if you have a lot of blemishes or uneven texture, whether that's large pores or bumps due to acne scarring. You'll probably need to reapply fairly regularly if you're oily.
Just a note on availability: most of the supermarkets I've seen this at don't have a very good selection of shades. Farmers and Kmart seem to have a wider selection, but I don't think we get the very darkest shades in NZ.
I bought this in shade 115 Ivory,which I think is the lightest shade out & it really suits my skin tone which is great. I apply directly onto my skin like war paint then blend it in with my fingers. I have found that this is the best way for me. It feels creamy when you apply it to your face, then almost powdery when you rub it in. It is nice to wear and it barely feels like you have anything on. This is a light coverage foundation and evens out my skin tone for when I just need to run into town & do some errands etc, but if I'm going out all day I would definitely want to apply something else over top to provide more coverage. As someone with combo-oily skin I think this foundation stays on for a decent length of time before it starts to melt off and for the price, does quite a good job. I will definitely be re-purchasing this product & might give some of the other products in this range a go as well & see how they perform together.