Oh my God my review disappeared her OK, Ill retype it! First of all I was almost in happy tears when I opened up a message from BR Letting me know that I had WON this gorgeous eyeliner! The day the it arrived I was so excited, I took it out of its blister pack, took off my eye makeup and dove right in.. I must admit that it looked/felt kind of strange using this angled pen, as I'm used to a normal straight type pen style.. But, wow it made it so super duper easy to get right up close and line a teensy perfect line on my upper lash line. Can't say it made my wing liner any easier though, but I do love how brilliantly it helped with my normal eye line. It is intensely pigmented which I love (because if it says it's "black", it better B-L-A-C-K)!! As I live in Auckland it can get super humid out of nowhere, and not so great eyeliner ends up looking like something out of a horror flick, I was super impressed by how smudge proof it was, yes no panda eyes here YAY?! :-) The lid is an awesome twist on lid, which trips me up every time I used it as I push in instead of twist lol, this will no doubt help with longevity by not drying out. I am a true convert to this eyeliner and with the brilliant Maybelline brand having sales constantly, it would be easy to get it on sale or with 2 for 1 deals etc.